Skip to main content

You’re probably making these 3 mistakes when you’re preparing baked chicken

Just say no to overcooked chicken

Roasted chicken
dbreen/pixabay

Baking chicken is one of those things that most homes probably do a few times a week. Chicken is delicious, crowd (and kid)-pleasing, generally pretty healthy, and usually simple enough when it comes to cooking. Whether you’re roasting an entire bird for a group or just preparing a single baked chicken breast for one, there are a few mistakes we’re all guilty of making from time to time. Mistakes that are easy to avoid if you know what to do. That’s where we come in.

Raw chicken breasts
Narsil/Adobe Stock

Starting with cold chicken

You may have heard this tip around Thanksgiving for roasting a perfect turkey (if not, take heed), but the same goes for pieces of chicken – and all other poultry and meats, in fact. We’re all guilty – perhaps in a rush to get dinner on the table – of grabbing a protein out of the fridge and tossing it directly into the pot or pan in about as much time as it takes to get the package open. Look, we’ve all been there, but for the best-ever baked chicken, try to have a little more patience.

Bringing chicken to room temperature is an important step for an evenly cooked piece of meat. Just as with roasting an entire bird, cold chicken pieces will not cook evenly, and you may have a raw inside and burned skin. Nobody wants these things, so plan ahead.

Person washing raw chicken in sink
Evgen / Adobe Stock

Washing chicken

The moment I think this bad habit is over once and for all, I talk to someone new or see some “influencer” on social media who still thinks washing raw chicken is a good idea. This is one of those frustrating cooking habits that became a normal thing to do ages ago before science came along and proved that it was, in fact, quite idiotic. While the concern of spreading salmonella and other bacteria through raw chicken is valid, you’re actually doing far more harm than good by running raw chicken under the tap in your kitchen sink. Washing or rinsing raw chicken under running water increases the risk of spreading these harmful bacteria all over your kitchen because it’s likely to splash and spread all over your countertops, sink, other dishes, faucet, and whatever else you have lying around. Plus, there’s no need to “wash the bacteria off” because chicken isn’t consumed raw. Any bacteria that may have found its way onto your chicken will be burned off in the cooking process anyway. So turn off the sink.

Thinly sliced chicken breasts
Alesia Berlezova / Adobe Stock

Cooking breasts whole

Chicken breasts have gotten to be massive in the last couple of decades. While the average size is still technically just about six ounces, it isn’t unusual to see a chicken breast closer to 10 or even 12 ounces. They’re also rather oddly shaped, varying in thickness depending on the side of the breast. This is why it’s always a good idea to create even chicken pieces, no matter how you’ll be preparing your dish. You can do this by pounding chicken with a meat mallet, which will also tenderize the meat in the process. You can also slice the breast into thinner, more even pieces that will cook evenly and more quickly. Evening out the chicken pieces will make it easier to have a consistent, even cook throughout the chicken, without having to worry about sections being over or undercooked.

This is also a tremendously important step to avoid the most common of chicken-related sins – overcooking. Overcooking chicken, especially breasts, is a tragedy that just doesn’t need to happen as often as it does. Uneven chicken is arguably the biggest cause of overcooked chicken because, by the time the thickest portion of the chicken is juicy and perfect, the rest of the piece has been a rubbery, stringy, chewy disaster for several minutes already. Say no to overcooked chicken and pound that bird into an even piece.

Editors' Recommendations

Lindsay Parrill
Lindsay is a graduate of California Culinary Academy, Le Cordon Bleu, San Francisco, from where she holds a degree in…
How to make the perfect carnitas, according to a chef
Check out these tips and tricks to make chef-worthy carnitas
Pork carnitas tacos

If you’ve ever had street tacos, whether from an actual street vendor or an upscale restaurant, you’ve likely had carnitas — whether you knew it or not. Carnitas grew in popularity through Mexican street tacos, but people use it in various dishes, from nachos to chimichangas. Carnitas are most commonly known to be pork, but it can really be any sort of meat cooked in its own fat (confit). The word carnitas in Spanish translates to "little meats."

You can learn how to make carnitas at home -- it isn't difficult. However, it’s not just a matter of throwing a chunk of pork in a pot, and then it turns into delicious carnitas. There are some crucial steps to cooking the perfect batch of carnitas. That’s why we reached out to an expert in Mexican cuisine.

Read more
Don’t make this super common mistake when chilling wine in an ice bucket
Chill your wine easily without the need for any expensive equipment.
Rose wine in ice bucket

When it comes to chilling wine, there are countless ways to get the job done. The market is saturated with products made specifically for cooling wine down to the perfect drinking temperature, from luxurious wine refrigerators to elegant marble wine chillers. We can almost guarantee that the passionate wine lover in your life probably has a pantry full of these fancy contraptions, each one more exciting (and expensive) than the last. After all, wine is an art and enjoying it at the correct temperature is an absolute must. At the end of the day, though, even with all the bells and whistles, it's hard to beat a good old-fashioned ice bath - especially when trying to cool down that wine in a hurry. But, as simple as this wine-chilling technique may be, it is possible to get it wrong. That's why we've collected a few tips and tricks for getting that wine chilled exactly right every time.
Order matters when chilling wine

While the more aesthetically pleasing option may be to fill your favorite wine chilling bucket with ice and simply nestle in your favorite bottle or two, this method is actually pretty ineffective when it comes to chilling wine in a pinch. By dumping ice into a container and plopping the wine on top, only the bottom half of the bottle will actually chill. It's important to fully cover your wine (or other beverage) bottles with ice so that the entire bottle has a chance to actually get cold. Do this by putting your bottle(s) in the bucket first, and then topping with ice - not the other way around. The more the bottle is covered with ice, the better. While this might not get you the sexiest photo shoot of your wine luxuriously resting in an ice bath, it's the better way to get the contents cold.
Use water and...salt?

Read more
How to make a buttery hollandaise sauce like a professional chef
Here's everything you need to know about this mother sauce
Eggs Benedict from Hash Kitchen

As Chef Joey Maggiore of the Arizona Brunch restaurant chain Hash Kitchen said, "Perfecting hollandaise is not necessarily the hardest, but it is a less forgiving sauce. You must pay attention to detail when making hollandaise so that you get the consistency and taste you need for the perfect sauce." Chef Maggiore couldn't be more spot on. Hollandaise is one of the five mother sauces, meaning, it's the base sauce for other, more complex sauces like béarnaise, choron, and maltaise sauces.

Before the technological age of blenders, the old-school method of making the perfect hollandaise sauce took some practice. But now, with technology, there are more foolproof ways to make the mother sauce. We'll cover all those methods, plus give you some of Chef Maggiore's tips and tricks on how to make hollandaise sauce. Also, stick around until the end for an easy hollandaise sauce recipe.
Hollandaise sauce ingredients

Read more