Skip to main content

A guide to making a Rob Roy, the Scotch lover’s classic

Add this drink to you home bar menu for your next gathering

Bobby Burns cocktailr Rob Roy riff
Alaincouillaud / Getty Images

Of the many classic cocktails worthy of your time, the Rob Roy may have the best name. The title itself is friendly and hard to forget, not unlike the drink itself. The hypnotic hue of the drink as it shrinks into the base of a Nick and Nora glass is reason enough to adore the Rob Roy, but there are many more merits to this mixed beverage.

Essentially a Manhattan with Scotch whisky, the Rob Roy cocktail was born in 1894. Inherently classy, the drink was devised in the iconic Waldorf Astoria Hotel in New York City. The Manhattan came first, concocted a couple of decades earlier. With the name of its home borough already taken, the creators opted to honor the Broadway premiere of an operetta released at the time about the legendary Scottish outlaw and folk hero Robert Roy MacGregor.

Like a martini, it’s typically served up dressed with a pair of cherries. There are three slightly different variations — sweet (made with sweet vermouth), dry (made with dry vermouth), and perfect, an even mix of the two. Like many of its classic counterparts, the Rob Roy is straightforward on the surface. But if you want this evocative drink to really speak to you, it’s imperative to both nail the few ingredients at play and execute the assembly.

With the vermouth playing a rather large role, having to stand up to Scotch without another spirit to cut into it, it’s critical to go with a well-made option. Certainly, play around with small-batch vermouths from your favorite producers, but if you’re looking for reliable, seek out something like Carpano Antica or Cocchi di Torino.

Speaking of Scotch, a balanced, blended option is best here. We love a peaty Islay, but the smokiness can fully sabotage a Rob Roy. Remember that we’re playing off of the botanical, wine-like nature of vermouth, not burying it. Try a lighter whisky, like the one in the classic recipe below or a more delicate option, like a lot of what’s coming out of Japan at the moment.

The Rob Roy’s only downfall may be its ties to the half-drunk, day-sipping era of the mid-20th century. And while the cocktail enjoyed a bit more popularity then, it’s evolved a bit since and remains a staple drink. Try a lower-proof Scotch or 1.5 ounces of Scotch instead of the traditional 2 to bring it into the modern era. In today’s cocktail culture, lighter — even if only marginally so — is often better.

Chilling is pretty important with a drink like this, as it tempers the Scotch some. As you make one (or a large format batch) at home, remember to stir with ice as well as pour into a pre-chilled glass, for maximum coolness. A little lemon is recommended, especially when preparing a dry version of the drink. The juice from a single lemon twist, often used as a garnish for the style, is typically enough, but trust your palate and adjust accordingly.

Classic Rob Roy cocktail recipe

Rob Roy cocktail with cherry garnish
Christian Kargl / Getty Images

You can’t touch a classic. Here, a fine Scotch meshes with the fig and herb notes of a classic vermouth. Even better, the drink is further aromatized via bitters and treated to the ultimate garnish in the brandied cherry.

Ingredients

  • 2 ounces Balvenie Doublewood 12-year Scotch whisky
  • 3/4 ounce Carpano Antica Formula vermouth
  • 1 dash Angostura bitters
  • 1 brandied cherry for garnish

Method

  1. Stir all ingredients over ice.
  2. Strain it into a chilled glass.
  3. Garnish with the brandied cherry.

Other versions of the Rob Roy cocktail

Manhattan
Drew Beamer / Unsplash

Above, we have the classic Rob Roy, but there are some twists on the classic. Depending on your tastes, you can mix it up with the following versions.

  • Dry Rob Roy: This version swaps the sweet vermouth for dry vermouth, resulting in a drier and less sweet cocktail.
  • Perfect Rob Roy: This variation uses equal parts sweet and dry vermouth, creating a more balanced sweetness level compared to the classic Rob Roy.
  • Bobby Burns: This twist gets a bit more adventurous, replacing the Angostura bitters with Benedictine, a herbal liqueur that adds a touch of sweetness and complexity.
  • Boulevardier: This cocktail essentially combines a Rob Roy and a Negroni. Keep the Scotch, but swap the sweet vermouth for Byrrh (a fortified wine) and use Campari instead of Angostura bitters. This results in a more bitter and herbal drink.
  • Manhattan (sort of): Since the Rob Roy is essentially a Manhattan made with Scotch instead of rye or bourbon, you can simply swap the Scotch for those whiskeys for a classic Manhattan experience.

Editors' Recommendations

Mark Stock
Mark Stock is a writer from Portland, Oregon. He fell into wine during the Recession and has been fixated on the stuff since…
These unique summer cocktails each offer a refreshing twist you’ll love
Need a great cocktail for the core of summer? Here are some ideal options
Summer cocktails

Summer stands for fun, from vacations to meandering Vespa rides. If you want to keep the carefree and celebratory spirit alive all season long, may we suggest some quality cocktails?

The merits of summer cocktails are many. First, they cool you off during the hottest portion of the year. Secondly, they tend to incorporate seasonal ingredients that taste their best right that instant. Lastly, they're just fun to make, whether you're hosting a backyard party or just looking to tip a cap to happy hour on your lonesome.

Read more
Here’s our perfect Pisco Sour recipe
Homemade pisco sour cocktail with lime and bitters

Claimed as a national drink by both Peru and Chile, the pisco sour has captivated cocktail lovers for over a century. Tart and sweet, with herbaceous and earthy notes and a rich, smooth finish, this South American gem suits any occasion. The success of this foamy, vibrantly hued beverage owes everything to pisco, its bold, complicated base spirit. Like brandy, pisco is a high-proof spirit made by distilling fermented grape juice, and it comes in a dizzying array of varieties.
Pisco sour recipe

Ingredients:

Read more
The best spritz cocktail recipes to drink this spring
Spring is the perfect time to mix it up with spritz cocktails. Let us show you how to make some tasty ones
Grapefruit sprtiz cocktail

The spritz is liquid springtime, using the power of sparkling wine and the floral nature of this time of year. The classic involves prosecco and Aperol, but that's merely one of countless permutations to make and enjoy this iconic sipper. Think of it as a fizzy cooler, a drinkable bouquet cut to your liking based on your favorite accents, aromatics, and mixers.

While we advise you to go with the Italian classic and use the famous bitter apéritif at least some of the time, we also want you to be curious and inventive. Like the Old Fashioned or a classic Negroni, the spritz is so much more than one thing, and it's very much worth plunging into and fully exploring. And there's no better time to do so than the thawing, rejuvenating, increasingly thirsty days of spring.

Read more